Judge.me founder says AI answers 73% of support chats

Judge.me founder PJ Celis says AI replies to 73% of the company’s support chats. In a 16 November post, he also estimated that 30–40% of conversations involve AI on the merchant’s side, based on…

Will Slatton2 min read

Judge.me founder PJ Celis says AI replies to 73% of the company’s support chats. In a 16 November post, he also estimated that 30–40% of conversations involve AI on the merchant’s side, based on their wording and length. The distinction matters: one figure describes his company’s support operation; the other is his judgement about incoming messages.

AI replies are not the same as autonomous resolutions

Celis said 27% of chats reach humans, and about 10% of that group are resolved by people using internal AI tools to compose the response. Those percentages have different denominators. His prediction that support could soon become predominantly AI-to-AI is a forecast, not a measured result.

The post does not provide a sampling period, independent audit or customer-satisfaction results. It cannot establish the share of AI support across Shopify apps, or show that automated replies solve problems as well as human replies.

Founders disagree about the right policy

In the replies, Erikas Mališauskas reported that AI was good at solving problems but less effective at generating five-star reviews. He suggested customers might be more inclined to review when helping a person. That is an observation and proposed explanation, not a controlled comparison.

TxtCart founder Kyle Bigley described a different approach: his company, which invests in human support, had decided not to accept AI-written requests or bots acting for customers. The exchange shows that app teams need an explicit policy, rather than assuming every vendor will welcome an agent’s message.

Measure the outcome of the conversation

Our recommendation is to separate response automation from resolution quality. Track repeat contacts, escalation, time to a verified fix and satisfaction alongside the share of replies produced by AI. A high automation percentage alone cannot tell a merchant whether a broken workflow was repaired.

Accepting an assistant’s question should also be separate from authorising account changes. Confirm the merchant’s identity and permission before refunds, data exports or configuration changes, whichever tool composed the request. Keep a clear route to a person when the request is ambiguous.

For a related operational example, see our coverage of Beardbrand’s founder account of AI phone support.

ℹ️
These are one founder’s company figures and estimates, not an industry benchmark. AI answering a chat does not prove the issue was resolved.
Filed underAI

More from AI

See all →